June 11, 2014

Battling Back: Advice for Challenging Cannabis Licensing Lotteries, Application Processes

lottery

By Fred Dreier

A growing number of states are implementing strict cannabis laws that limit the number of marijuana businesses, using lotteries or complex scoring systems to determine who gets a license.

Many qualified entrepreneurs have been shut out of the industry as a result. But not all of them have gone quietly into the night.

Unsuccessful applicants in Massachusetts have filed lawsuits challenging state licensing processes, while a handful of entrepreneurs who walked away empty-handed from Washington State’s lottery for recreational permits are threatening to take legal action.

The Massachusetts lawsuits are still working their way through the courts, so it’s still too early to say whether this type of legal action can help reverse state licensing decisions or lead to an overhaul of the process. Still, licensing lawsuits could become increasingly common around the country going forward, regardless of the outcome.

Marijuana Business Daily spoke with several lawyers for advice on when to pursue legal action and steps you can take to bolster your case.

Sour Grapes, Confusion Not Enough

Whether businesses should sue state agencies has become a polarizing question in the cannabis industry, since lawsuits could bog down the entire process and delay businesses from opening.

In many cases, licensing lawsuits are simply a last gasp by unlucky entrepreneurs who are trying to recoup on their investments, several lawyers said. Others resulted from confusion over application rules – which can be tough cases to win.

“The real culprit was a lack of communication between the state regulatory body, the zoning bodies and the [applicant],” said Ryan Hurley, who represented several clients during Arizona’s dispensary licensing process., which involved a lottery. “Unfortunately, once the decisions had been made, it was impossible to go back in time.”

Lawyers in Washington State echoed Hurley’s opinion. Officials there conducted a lottery for recreational retail licenses in May, and the Washington State Liquor Control Board hopes to approve the first retail licenses in July.

Hilary Bricken, an attorney with Canna Law Group in Seattle, said nothing short of an emergency injunction issued by the state court would delay Washington’s licensing process now. Plaintiffs would need to exhaust their administrative remedies in lower courts before getting their case into state court, which would simply take too much time.

“I don’t see any of those actions against the board having much traction,” Bricken said.

When You Might Have a Case

Entrepreneurs who missed out on a license should consider filing suit in a handful of situations: if they can prove that less-qualified businesses were accepted; if they can prove that corruption, favoritism or gross negligence by officials was at play during the licensing; or if the lawsuit can place the plaintiff back into the pool of applicants.

“My advice to lawyers who jump in is to raise arguments, defend the applicant’s rights and demand a fair treatment,” said Dick Evans, a Massachusetts lawyer who represented an unsuccessful client. “We’re talking about justice here.”

Proving this requires extensive legwork. Massachusetts lawyer Bob Carp, who has filed three separate lawsuits against the Massachusetts Health Department, said he required prospective clients to fill out an intake sheet to determine if their case held water.

On the sheet, Carp asked each client to provide their the score card from the health department and from local officials, as well as the score card of the license winner in the same jurisdiction.

The score sheet is just one of the important documents that plaintiffs should keep, Carp said. They should also hold onto emails and letters with officials, as well as lease information or deeds to property.

Carp and his team scanned the documents for inconsistencies in scoring. If the client had a low score, Carp passed.

If he found inconsistencies, Carp proceeded to the next step. He examined the winning application for the jurisdiction and then checked the company’s paperwork against the 55-page book of rules issued by the health department.

“In some cases we have very solid documented proof that [the agency] had no idea what they were doing,” Carp said. “But to do that we had to go through almost every single application.”

Finally, Carp said he only pursued the lawsuit if there was a chance to reinstate his clients into the pool of applicants. A judge recently ruled that Carp’s lawsuit could not stop the dispensary licensing process from continuing, however courts have yet to make a decision on the lawsuit itself.

Talk to the Media

Both Carp and Evans stressed the importance of communicating with the media during the lawsuit. Evans said it was the constant reporting on the Department of Public Health’s mishandling of the Massachusetts licensing that likely persuaded some plaintiffs to come out of the woodwork.

“There was this constant drip, drip, drip of reporting on the alleged favoritism and what seemed to be a flawed process,” he said. “That [information] really called into question the design of the process.”

Carp said plaintiffs should keep regular communication going with reporters. His advice is to be “laser pointed” with media communications. Instead of making blanket statements such as “the process was unjust,” plaintiffs should give specifics, such as bullet-point guidelines showing exactly where the process went wrong.

“If you can build credibility and explain it in layman terms, the press will be more comfortable with you,” Carp said.

Positive media attention could help public sentiment sway in favor of the plaintiffs, which in turn could influence policymakers.

“You want to show that it’s not just unhappy applicants,” Evans said.

Go it Alone

Entrepreneurs may be enticed to band together in their fight against state agencies and file a class-action lawsuit. But it might be better to stay separate, Evans said.

For starters, filing an individual lawsuit allows you to be more nimble.

“Class action lawsuits can get big and clunky,” Evans said. “They are expensive and can last a lot longer.”

Carp, who has won class-action suits in the past, agreed. From a strategic standpoint, it is better for multiple parties to file individual suits, versus filing one big suit, because the defendant will be forced to deal with all of the parties individually. That can spread resources thin.

Class-action suits are also considerably more expensive.

mjfactbook14storyhorizontal336 e1397581896865 Battling Back: Advice for Challenging Cannabis Licensing Lotteries, Application ProcessesCarp also said class-action suits can be pushed into federal court, which could dismiss the suit because the argument concerns a controlled substance.

“You want to keep [the lawsuit] within the confines of the district court or the superior court because they will work with the statutes that are on the state books,” Carp said. “Federal court would dismiss you with prejudice, which would end any hope you have.”


2 Comments:

  1. Clifton Middleton

    This is the same set of obstructionist and anti marijuana forces that have been in favor of criminializing everyone who uses marijuana. We overcame the cops and legislators who came back as regulators and overlords. The courts will not help, they are part and parcel of big pharma, the alcohol industry and the still mad about the people’s victory but direct vote.

  2. I would have to agree with the attorneys in the article. I’ve been involved with hundreds of liquor license cases and any MMJ case would be similar.

    Daniel Rubinow
    LicenseLawGroup.com

Post Your Comment:


Please note:
Comments are moderated by our editors who do their best to approve comments ASAP. As Marijuana Business Daily is focused on business, we approve comments that are specifically relevant to industry professionals. General opinions and questions about cannabis may not be posted.

Group Looking to Expand Minnesota’s MMJ Patient Base

Many cannabis advocates in Minnesota think that the state’s medical marijuana program is much too [click to continue...]

Marijuana Business Incubator Launches in Florida

Whether or not medical marijuana passes in Florida on Tuesday, Tampa will be home to [click to continue...]

Young Voters Could Make or Break Legalization Measures

Photo for medical marijuana election

The success of several marijuana measures on the ballot next week could ultimately hinge on [click to continue...]

Estimate: Legal Rec Sales in DC Could Create $130M Market

The cannabis market in Washington DC could top $130 million annually if the city legalizes [click to continue...]

67 Warnings, Penalties for MJ Violations in Washington

When it comes to recreational marijuana, enforcement of the law is no laughing matter for [click to continue...]

Oregon Rec Legalization a Coin Flip

marijuana election

Recreational marijuana could be a nail-biter in Oregon on Election Day. A poll released this [click to continue...]

Chile Plants First Medical Cannabis Crop

The first legal medical marijuana plants were seeded in Chile on Wednesday as part of [click to continue...]

Maryland Delays Vote on MMJ Regs, Plans to Lower Fees

A Maryland commission postponed a final vote on medical marijuana regulations, saying the 15-member panel [click to continue...]

Super-Potent Strain a Top Seller in WA

Medical marijuana regulations, cannabis laws and general MMJ news

High-potency strains are a big hit with customers in Washington State’s new recreational market, it [click to continue...]

CO Company Sues Shareholder Over Trading Halt

A publicly traded cannabis company has filed suit against a major shareholder, alleging he caused [click to continue...]

Expert: Liability Lawsuits Next Challenge for Edibles Companies

A Seattle attorney warned hundreds of industry insiders at a business conference on Tuesday that [click to continue...]

‘Very Large’ Raid Operation Targets Denver Cultivation Sites

Denverpolice

Police officers and federal agents raided multiple marijuana growing operations in Denver on Tuesday, saying [click to continue...]

Former FBI Official Joins Cannabis Company’s Board

Medbox Inc., a publicly traded software and consulting firm that makes marijuana dispensing machines, has [click to continue...]

NM Marijuana Grower Loses Bid to Reopen Licensing Process

Mark Springer really wants to grow medical marijuana in New Mexico. So much so that [click to continue...]